Record your initial reactions to the text. Jog your memory for any literature you've read or documentaries you've seen that might be useful for evaluating the article. Method 1 Quiz What will help you create a legend? Reading the article through once to understand the main idea.
Taking notes as you read. Developing unique symbols that will help you understand your markups. Asking yourself questions as you read through the article. Question whether the writer's overall message is logical. Test the hypothesis and compare it to other similar examples. Examine the author's introduction and conclusion to make sure they match up as convincing and complementary elements.
Search the article for any biases, whether intentional or unintentional. If the author has anything to gain from the conclusions demonstrated in the article, it's possible that some bias has been demonstrated.
Well-sourced opinions are perfectly OK, but those without academic support deserve to be met with a skeptical eye. Bias can also come from a place of prejudice. Note any biases related to race, ethnicity, gender, class, or politics. Consider the author's interpretations of other texts. If the author makes a claim about another's work, read the original work and see if you agree with the analysis provided in the article.
Such conflict may bear fruit when it comes time to write your review. See what other scholars have to say. If several scholars from diverse backgrounds have the same opinion about a text, that opinion should be given more weight than an argument with little support. Notice if the author cites untrustworthy evidence. Does the author cite an irrelevant text from fifty years ago that no longer holds weight in the discipline at hand?
If the author cites unreliable sources, it greatly diminishes the credibility of the article. Pay attention to obscure word choices and the author's tone throughout the article. This is particularly helpful for non-scientific articles dealing with aspects of literature, for example.
For example, an article written in a heated, overzealous tone might be ignoring or refusing to engage with contradictory evidence in its analysis. Always look up the definitions of unfamiliar words. A word's definition can completely change the meaning of a sentence, especially if a particular word has several definitions. Question why an author chose one particular word instead of another, and it might reveal something about their argument. Question research methods in scientific articles.
If critiquing an article containing a scientific theory, be sure to evaluate the research methods behind the experiment. Ask yourself questions such as these: Is the study designed without major flaws? Is there a problem with the sample size? Was a control group created for comparison? Are all of the statistical calculations correct? Would another party be able to duplicate the experiment in question?
Is the experiment significant for that particular field of study? Use your existing knowledge, educated opinions, and any research you can gather to either support or disagree with the author's article. Provide empirical arguments to support your stance.
Make sure each source provides something unique to your critique. Additionally, don't allow your use of sources to crowd out your own opinions and arguments. Remember that a critique doesn't have to be entirely positive or negative. You can provide contradictory evidence to an argument while still maintaining that a particular point of view is the correct one. Forcefully express your defensible points of agreement and disagreement.
Method 2 Quiz What are examples of biases you may find in an article? Misappropriating evidence to make false conclusions. Including personal, unfounded opinions. Blaming a specific race for a problem. All of the above. Begin with an introduction that outlines your argument. The introduction should be no more than two paragraphs long and should lay out the basic framework for your critique. Start off by noting where the article in question fails or succeeds most dramatically and why.
The introduction is not the place to provide evidence for your opinions. Your evidence will go in the body paragraphs of your critique. Be bold in your introductory assertions and make your purpose clear right off the bat. Skirting around or not fully committing to an argument lessens your credibility. Provide evidence for your argument in the body paragraphs of your critique. Each body paragraph should detail a new idea or further expand your argument in a new direction.
Don't feel like you have to condense the entire paragraph into the topic sentence, however. This is purely a place to transition into a new or somehow different idea. End each body paragraph with a transitional sentence that hints at, though does not explicitly state, the content of the paragraph coming next. For example, you might write, "While John Doe shows that the number of cases of childhood obesity is rising at a remarkable rate in the U.
Complicate your argument near the end of the critique. No matter how solid your argument is, there is always at least one dramatic way in which you can provide a final twist or take your argument one step further and suggest possible implications.
Do this in the final body paragraph before your conclusion to leave the reader with a final, memorable argument. You might, for instance, utilize a counterargument, in which you anticipate a critique of your critique and reaffirm your position. Present your arguments in a well-reasoned, objective tone. Avoid writing in an overzealous or obnoxiously passionate tone, as doing so can be a turn-off to many readers. Let your passion shine through in your ability to do thorough research and articulate yourself effectively.
Conclude your critique by summarizing your argument and suggesting potential implications. It is important to provide a recap of your main points throughout the article, but you also need to tell the reader what your critique means for the discipline at large. Do your best to make a lasting mark on the reader in the conclusion by using assertive language to demonstrate the importance of your work: Method 3 Quiz What should you include in the introduction to your critique?
The title of the article. Possible implications of the author's arguments. Identify the claims made in the article, and determine whether they are supported by convincing evidence and clearly expressed. Look for strengths and weaknesses in the content and style of the article, and provide supported evidence regarding ways in which the article could be improved.
Not Helpful 1 Helpful What do you mean by "A critic does not have to be entirely positive or entirely negative"? People tend to view the terms critic or criticism in a negative light, but in fact they refer in this context to a detailed, defensible analysis of the content and claims in another's work. A good critique doesn't have to rip the article to shreds, nor does it need to hail it as the greatest thing since sliced bread.
Rather, try to identify the various strengths and weaknesses in the piece under review. Not Helpful 4 Helpful Follow many of the same guidelines you would use critiquing a scholarly article. Ask yourself whether the learning objective clearly presents its main concepts and establishes their importance; whether the organization, structure, and content are sensible and easy to follow; and how you would approach it differently and why.
Not Helpful 1 Helpful 9. Make sure you've read the medical case report. Then, evaluate the information in the case report for accuracy, usefulness, etc. Not Helpful 2 Helpful 8. Ask yourself questions like: Is this map easy to follow? Does it provide the necessary information? Are there any biases or limitations that become obvious when looking at this map?
How does it compare to similar maps? How might I have created this map differently, and why? Not Helpful 2 Helpful 5. Answer this question Flag as What are some ideas for a critical essay on an article describing services? What are some ideas for a critical response to a piece about animation in architectural design?
What are some ways to write a critical essay about a key witness in a murder case? What are some ways to write a critical essay on an article about health? Include your email address to get a message when this question is answered. Already answered Not a question Bad question Other. By using this service, some information may be shared with YouTube.
Quick Summary To critique an article, first read it and take notes on the author's overall argument to help you develop a preliminary opinion. Did this summary help you? Warnings Avoid style-based critiques that include comments such as "I liked it" or "It was written poorly. Avoid summarizing the article at all costs. It is better to write a shorter critique than to attempt to fill up blank space with boring summation.
Tips Write your critique in the third person and present tense, unless the style indicates another preference. Always review the style guidelines prior to starting to write.
Write with confidence and bold assertion. You can use a quote from the text or another outside source, a statistic, a fact or information from the text itself. In the introduction of your critique paper, you must also summarize the text that you are critiquing. Although your own critique needs to be firm, you can use this part to give a brief overview of the text you're analyzing, while emphasizing the author's main point and purpose. You may also want to write a brief counterargument in one sentence, just to give the reader an idea of what the opposing views are.
Every critique paper must have a thesis statement. Your thesis is how you summarize your argument which supports the critique your giving. This should be your opinion or a very brief overview of your thoughts on the text.
You don't want to give everything away, but you can continue to draw the reader in by writing a sentence or two that firmly states your opinion and the critique you're about to draw out.
An introduction should not be more than two paragraphs maximum. That, of course, does not give you a lot of space to squeeze in all the necessary points. However, it's necessary that when writing the introduction, that you also mention the title of the text and information about the author. She has spent the last 5 years traveling the world and living abroad and has lived in South Korea and Israel.
Before becoming a writer, Hana worked as a teacher for several years. Hana enjoys reading, cooking, and watching foreign films. The database based on Word Net is a lexical database for the English Language. Tip Write the introduction last. After writing the rest of your paper and re-reading it, you may be able to more clearly articulate a summary of your argument.
References Very Well Mind: Writing a Critique Studyskills Southwales: How to Write a Critique. How to Start a Critique Paper.
One of the most popular formatting styles, while completing an article critique is American Psychological Association (APA) format, which has its specific rules and guidelines. Your paper should be double-spaced, using 1-inch margins and Times New Roman font in 12 point.
Here is a really good example of a scholary research critique written by a student in EDRS The student who submitted this paper last semester earned a on his critique. The content of the paper .
Academic writing and more specifically, “how to write a critique essay” problem, is simple once you have explicit instructions on how to go about the process and the required article format. The following are the steps that will guide you in becoming competent in the field of writing article critique with little effort. Not sure what a proper article critique writing looks like? Check our offers and find the best article writing help here. No plagiarism and timely delivery are guaranteed!
Mar 05, · Using an appropriate article critique example to understand the essential steps on how to critique an article and yield the best result in your research paper/5(92). Critique papers require students to conduct a critical analysis of another piece of writing, often a book, journal article, or essay. No matter what your major is, you will probably be expected to write a critique paper at some point.